Framing Devices and Games-within-Games
Framing devices and games-within-games
This is the fourth essay in my series about metagames in tabletop RPGs. This essay is about framing devices and games-within-games. I wrote it in preparation for publishing Mousetrap: A cursed game-within-a-game that won't go back into its box.

In fiction, a framing device is a hierarchical structure applied to multiple levels of fiction. The frame is the top or outer level, encapsulating a set of smaller narratives or a single story within it. For example, 1001 Nights, The Decameron, and The Canterbury Tales all involve a frame in which characters tell stories of their own. And these stories-within-a-story can include “nested” stories within them.
Tabletop RPGs use framing devices as well. And sometimes they are not simply stories. They can be games — a game-within-a-game.
During character creation for the DIE RPG, it may seem like you are heading toward an RPG-within-a-RPG, but just before the embedded game can begin, your personas (or fictional players) are “transformed” into their characters when “they are all transported to a fantasy world based on their old roleplaying game world.”
The game is set within the fictional game world. Your personas’ broader “reality” frames the conflicts that they engage in for their fantasy world — and their fantasy conflicts frame our revelations of their memories and experiences from the real world: once per game, players can employ “a real-world flashback,” which is “when a player recalls an event in the real world to provide insight or motivation into a current problem.”
In contrast, 1001 Nights by Meguey Baker and her imprint Night Sky Games may sound like a game of embedded stories, which is true, but I would argue that it is also a game-within-a-game. In 1001 Nights, the topmost fictional layer is the Sultan’s court. As a player, you take on the role of a member at this court, whiling away the sultry nights by telling pointed stories. As characters you declare your interests in stories by wagering gems (dice), and if they pay off, they help your character advance their own ambitions, protect you from the Sultan’s wrath, or grant you your freedom. When it is your courtier’s turn to tell a story, you become the “GM.” But you are not GM for the frame story, truly your character becomes the GM for the game within the game, assigning roles and unfurling a story for others to act within.
Why Framing Devices?
In fiction, an author might use framing devices for a variety of reasons. One common strategy is to use the frame story to predispose the reader toward the embedded story. And sometimes inner stories tell readers something about the outer frame, implying something about the frame’s circumstances or the story’s narrator. Framing devices can function similarly in tabletop RPGs.
In DIE RPG, the flashbacks explicitly “provide insight or motivation into a current problem,” while also fleshing out the character in question. The game world is intended to echo the strengths and weaknesses, failures, losses and successes of the characters' lives outside of it. Even at the start of DIE, the GM is invited to explicitly frame the game and its world to players. What they say will impact how players view this world. For example, a GM may use the suggested language in the rulebook:
Hey—do you remember that thing back in the 1990s? Those kids who were playing an RPG and just disappeared. They were just gone. For two years, no-one had any idea where they were. When they turned back up, none of them ever talked about what happened. Well, you know what? I managed to get hold of a copy of the game off the Internet. Let’s play it.
People disappear from their real life for two years? They won’t talk about it? You got it off the Internet? Maybe this game is fishy. Perhaps, you should approach it skeptically.
Similarly in 1001 Nights, the stories that courtiers tell are intended to inform what happens at court. As Evan Torner writes,
The tale-within-a-tale enacts metaphors for the PCs’ diegetic concerns. A story told by the licentious cook ostensibly about a Pied Piper of Hamelin figure may actually turn out to be about competing desires for the handmaiden whom he cannot woo. A Sinbad action-adventure tale might turn into a rags-to-riches slapstick when told by a poor character in envy of wealthier characters. The metaphorization of real material through fictional forms and the ambiguities that creates lies at the heart of this game.
But the framing is even more deliciously complex than is immediately apparent, as 1001 Nights can also have stories nested within the courtier’s stories:
On occasion a story is like a flower opening, with layers inside layers. The great and powerful jiin may agree to help the noble young prince, but only if the prince can bring him the answer to the puzzle of the little bird. And so we set aside the Story of the jiin and the prince to follow the tale of the bird … Note that in casting the inner parts, the inner storyteller may counter the pointed commentary of the outer role.
The nested stories inform the outermost frame — while also potentially informing the circumstances and characters of the embedded story that frames it. And yet, the outer storyteller frames the listener’s attitude toward the nested story: do we have reason to doubt the veracity of their story?
But wait. Is this the outermost frame? As we imagine our characters seated around the room, telling stories, we might be reminded that we have our own external frame of reference, sitting around a room, telling stories.
Meguey Baker turns these frames or reference or layers of reality into dynamic spaces for tension to unfold between the storytellers or GMs.
Broken Frames
In a framing device, you may expect a frame that has introduced the work to conclude that work as well. DIE RPG, for example, provides three possible “endgames,” each of which point back to the “real world” for closure. Even if the characters choose to stay in DIE, they are invited to explain how their absence affects the real world, as are the players of any character who has died, no matter what decision the character’s make.
And yet, not all framing devices work in this way. In fact, there are plenty of examples of postmodern literature that problematize frames — where there is no end frame to provide closure, the frames are infinitely nesting, or the narrator enters the narrated world. These are works that draw attention to the fact that our perception of both reality and fiction is constructed through frames, and we can’t always distinguish where one frame ends and another begins. These authors challenge readers, leaving them wondering, dissatisfied, disoriented.
Many tabletop RPGs are accidentally postmodern.
That’s a joke, yet it’s true in that a game can supply a closing frame, as DIE RPG does, but the players may never reach that conclusion.
This is a self-indulgent tangent, but in tabletop RPGs for group play, you are an author and performer as much as you are an audience member, and you are also reliant on fellow players. You may lose one or more players who have been central in constructing the narrative or who are “the glue” to your game group, and the play ends prematurely for all players. Many long-form games incidentally leave their players with incomplete stories. And there are “infinite” games and sandbox settings that are meant to go on forever until they stop suddenly, sort of like a modern sitcom.
A lack of closure is a risk we accept by playing these long-form games, and we continue to play them anyway. Is that a “bug”? In some playstyles, it’s a feature: the journey matters more than the destination. You don’t know where the game will end, because the story is emergent. There is a chance you may never reach your destination. There is a structure to some OSR adventures, which is a clear hook or beginning, a crawl or sandbox in the middle, and then a “loose end.” Games with this structure can risk a less satisfying conclusion by some standards.
Perhaps endings and closure do not matter as much in a tabletop RPG than in another form? Or, at least, in certain genres of tabletop RPG.
And that isn’t to say that they don’t matter, especially in tightly designed short-form games. But — to bring it back around — there is certainly something that feels “authorized” about a premature ending in DIE RPG, whose fiction gestures toward trad play. A premature ending seems to be an appropriate ending for a tabletop RPG about this sort of tabletop RPG.
It feels appropriate in other ways too. You left your characters in a fictional game world. They remain there, trapped, or maybe their fictional reality collapsed after an implied “stalemate”? Either way, reality moves on without them:
Hey—do you remember that thing back in 2026? Those characters who went into an RPG world and disappeared. They were just gone.
Collapsing Frames
Beyond breaking frames, many works of art remind us that nothing is unmediated. Everything is framed, actually. Metagames (and metafiction, etc.) can accomplish this without conventional framing devices, because the act of playing a game is already a frame — the player’s frame of reference. Metareferences simply draw attention to this non-diegetic frame. This frame is especially important for tabletop RPGs, because players constantly navigate between the non-diegetic and diegetic rules as part of the composition of their fiction. The distinction between framed and unframed cannot be made.
As I mentioned in a previous essay, tabletop RPGs have various frames of reference or layers of reality:
- The external world that informs or distracts our game;
- The immediate conversational context in which we talk about the fiction and negotiate rules that are unavailable or invisible to characters;
- The fictional layer(s) in which the reality is narrated to us and within which we play as our characters operating within diegetic rules;
- The layer of embedded fiction(s) in which our characters dream up realities or may operate characters of their own.
- The rare layer of nested fictions in games like 1001 Nights.
You could say that bleed is the most common effect of the second layer collapsing into the third. And in metagames the second and third layers collapse into one another intentionally. Consider how in DIE RPG, the game world is “a 20-sided die, each of its twenty realms shaped by a Master” — which echoes the “reality” of “players” in the game while also gesturing toward the reality of the real players, who sit at a table with their dice and game master. In DIE RPG’s endgame, the final threat is that “reality collapses,” and “players” must choose which reality to live in.
Games-within-games are effective at collapsing these frames. In fact, this collapse plays out in the game text of 1001 Nights, when Baker describes the role of the GM for the game-within-a-game:
As GM, have your Courtier assign roles to the other Courtiers for the sake of the story. Here you may further your Courtier’s cause: assign the haughty Astrologer the role of the humble Sheep-boy… Opening the Story is your responsibility, but have no particular outcome in mind. Cast the courtiers into the Story and set them together in the scene, and then unfurl the Story just before the feet of the players — this is the GM’s role.
In this passage, Baker blurs roles between the courtier and player — which of these two becomes the “GM”? The player does, surely, but the courtier enacts the GM’s authority and role. They are the one who will “cast the courtiers into the Story and set them together in the scene, and then unfurl the Story” before their feet… and yet Baker tells us that “this is the GM’s role.” The second and third layers of reality collapse into one another to facilitate the embedded fiction.
Most metagames disrupt "immersion" by pointing to our frame of reference, the artificiality of the stories we were consuming. And yet, at this moment, the game is also very real. Fiction and reality touch one another through the magic circle as you embody your character, who is playing a game at the same time that you are.
Conclusion
I considered stopping mid-analysis to make a point about framing devices, but that would have been excessive.
Instead, to conclude this essay and the larger series, I want to ask, “Why consider framing devices, mini-games, breaking the magic circle, metagames?” It’s not about the novelty or to simply fill a void. I think these are relevant conversations for our design circles. These are conversations about the form and medium of tabletop RPGs.
I recognize that many tabletop RPG players may have a negative reaction to experimental or “postmodern” games. They may find them pretentious. They may want a game to be a world to escape into without thinking about how that escape works. They have the right.
But I also think that desire is tantalean. It runs contrary to the form of tabletop RPGs. Earlier I joked that many tabletop RPGs are accidentally postmodern. Recently I've been wondering if it’s not an accident. I’ve been wondering whether a sort of postmodern aesthetic gave rise to these games to begin with.
What I mean is that the tabletop RPG is a form that is skeptical of single, defined narratives. It is a form that invites multiple subjectivities to construct messy realities through a very general consensus. The tabletop RPG is a form that prevents its audience from passive engagement. It requires them to be present in their frame of reference, to be aware of our fiction’s artificiality while seeking to live within it. And it is a form that creates not only sympathy or empathy but bleed. It’s a form that can collapse its layers of fiction into something real.
A couple of people have suggested to me that a tabletop RPG’s game text is ergodic: It requires you to work, to assemble meaning and function. There is necessarily friction in both reading and assembly, no matter how much technical writing advice you apply. Moreover, through Rule Zero, influential traditions of RPGs have historically deauthorized the rest of the game text and encouraged home brewing – with Gygax writing in Alarums and Excursions, "Each campaign should be a 'variant,' and there is no 'official interpretation' from me or anyone else ... I will do my utmost to see that there is as little trend towards standardization as possible."
I want more metagames, more expressionist games, more ugly games and sicko games and experimental games. And really, they don't have to be metagames or postmodern. I just want more games that explore the form of tabletop RPGs in all of its weirdness, because the medium poses opportunities, distinct from literary fiction, drama, and video games. These games help us see the art form for what it is, at least in this moment.
Essays in This Series
- Essay: Let the Metagames Begin
- Essay: Breaking Fourth Walls and Magic Circles
- Essay: Mini-games and Fragmentation
- Essay: Framing Devices and Games-within-Games
Interviews in This Series
- Interview: Thomas Manuel on Theatre and RPGs
- Interview: Kienna Shaw on Your Magic Circle
- Interview: Emily Allen on The Yellow Curtain and Metagames
- Interview: Cornelia Foote on The Curse of Castle Muldoon